« Back To BSA Innovation Engine

agast

agast
Member since : Nov-24-2008 (Verified)
3 Ideas, 8 Comments, 142 Votes

User Activity Stream

Ideas Posted

I suspect that the time for Wood Badge has run its course in the BSA. The fraternal format of the program acts more as a social program than productive training.

Let's pull the valuable and effective leadership materials that are in the course, and infuse it into a new format. Or, at the least, redesign Wood Badge to be less fraternal, self-existing, and a drain on resources (Centennial Wood Badge?).

We need to keep the enthusiasm, energy, and material that Wood Badge graduates have, and do so in a way that does not create an adult fraternity atmosphere.
Moderator Comments
12/2/08
From: Gary Butler, Council Solutions Group Director

The Council Solutions Group has already had dialogue with the key volunteer founders of the 21st Century Woodbadge Course regarding the next evolution of the course. Preparations are being put into place to evaluate the strengths and challenges of the current course and determining what the next generation of Woodbadge might look like. As a strong proponent of the power of Woodbadge and its leadership methodolgy when administered correctly, I am personnally involved in supporting the efforts of the the volunteers and staff entrusted with this challenge.
The new BSA uniform was a needed change to appear relevant and appealing in today's American society. However, I don't think the change was progressive enough. Here are a few suggestions:
-Eliminate the shoulder loops and epaulets. They give the uniform an outdated look and realistically not needed.
-Eliminate the large cuffs on the sleeves. It gives the shirt a vintage look which we should avoid.
-Eliminate (or adapt) the should pocket. I think it was a good concept, but too many volunteers joke (and use) it as their cigarette pocket.
Moderator Comments
This idea has been assigned to the Innovation Team. We will include this suggestion in one of our upcoming team meetings and will keep you posted on the results.
A successful way to start new traditional units at religious insitutions is to turn the initial emphasis by focusing on the church's membership and organizing a faith-focused youth group. Name this group after the Scouting religious emblem for that group.

For example, at a Presbyterian Church organize a church youth group for 1-3 graders called God and Me. The first few meetings are focused on the Presbyterian Religious emblem (God and Me), with infused Cub Scout activities. As the religious program draws near to completion, transition to additional Cub Scout meeting programs and the Bobcat badge and outdoor programs, eventually delivering a full Scouting program.

This can be continued each year with a new class of youth enrolling in the faith-focused group and transitioning into Scouting. It can be used for youth of any age and Scouting program.

This method has several immediate benefits: 1) the chartered organization has more members participating in their Scouting program--creating increased support and better program delivery, 2) Scouting immediately develops demonstrated value by addressing the primary objective of the organization: faith, 3) parents are immediately engaged and active in the program by working side-by-side with their children.

Support for this kind of initiative can be provided to unit-serving executives through a generic toolkit. Not needing to be faith-specific, the new unit organization process can be amended to provide steps for church officials and Scouting volunteers. An additional resource could be the production of "den meeting in a box" style kits to assist religious institutions in delivering the program.
Moderator Comments
3/2/09
From: Sam Thompson, Membership Impact Department Manager

Good idea and currently being studied for future implementation.
Total Rows   401
Displaying 1 to 25

Comments Posted

agast 0 years ago
This is a recognition for the council and its board, not the Scout Executive.
agast 0 years ago
Have we ever considered a NESA membership discount for active Scouting leaders?
agast 0 years ago
I don't think the name makes any difference. I've averaged ~20 boys per school by following the plan. In any case, the only folks who would ever know what you call it are your leaders.
agast 0 years ago
I've used an automated phone system for regular phone calls to my Scoutreach families, and to promote district events. It's been highly effective in raising attendance at all.
agast 0 years ago
I believe the program is exceptional as designed. In fact, I believe part of the "fuzziness" extends from something that you did in your message: Venturing vs. Venture. These are two different programs of the BSA. Many old-time Scouters are thoroughly confused by this, and I commonly see professional staff refer to Venturing as Venture.
Let's delete the Venture program completely from Scouting.
And, let's focus a clear message to our Scouting community on what Venturing is, how it works, and why it is amazing!
agast 0 years ago
I believe the same arguement could be used for all programs: Cub Scout wanting to join Boy Scouts, and younger boys wanting to become Cub Scouts. This is a good thing! It creates anticipation and elevates the status.

The Venturing program works exceptionally well as designed, and the ages fit the program perfectly.

The solution is to develop a more solid recruiting plan for Venturing and market the program more publicly.
agast 0 years ago
In this aspect I think video games would have a negative connotation. But, video games are just one aspect of a much bigger (and growing) part of our world. How about an electronic arts merit badge, focusing on CGI, video game design, and other computer-generated artwork.
agast 0 years ago
Cub Scout program is designed specifically for boys. However, I agree that girls are left without an opportunity for a similar pursuit, built on the same foundation of the BSA. I would suggest an alternative: create a side-by-side program specifically for girls--another member of a full family of Scouting! Some program elements can be completed together-Blue & Gold Banquet, crossover, etc., while gender-specific activities are done separate.
Think about the opportunity to serve girls in elementary and middle school with a quality program as we do for boys! Programs can be designed side-by-side until 14-years old where they merge for Venturing.